RenalWEB links to an article from the Wharton School of the Univ. of Pennsylvania and a related bloq post from The Huffington Post that comments on and analyzes a new paper that looks to update the renal dialysis cost effectiveness standard. RenalWEB even offers a rare, blog-like commentary:
Dialysis patients whose treatment costs exceed $240,000 per QALY [quality-adjusted year of life] fall in the top 10%. The study points out that 50% of the Medicare's ESRD costs are used to treat the "sickest" 10% of dialysis patients.
The question is if and/or when this kind of cost data will be used to determine a patient's access to dialysis treatments. The study will appear in an upcoming issue of Value in Health.
I just can't explain these numbers. The coverage is tantalizing but it's clear I don't understand the key points. From the Knowledge@Wharton article:
However, the distribution of cost effectiveness across the entire population is wide. For the lowest percentile, it costs only $65,496 to provide an additional quality-adjusted life year. For the top percentile, the figure is $488,360. The higher costs per quality adjusted life year were strongly associated with old age and additional chronic illnesses in addition to end-stage renal disease, the researchers found.
I am afraid I can't make sense of this I am familiar with the USRDS numbers. As I would normally describe it, total Medicare spending for someone on Dialysis (not in a SNF) is about $55,000/year, since this is 80%, that puts total average total cost around $69,000. However the lowest percentile must be quite a bit less.
Taking myself as an example, my "cost" in 2007 it was almost entirely the composite rate, along with below average use of injectable medications (10% of average EPO use) and low use of medications that typically fall under Part D. I haven't added it all up but it must be in the $15,000 to $20,000 range when including physician fees. So, at least for 2007, I reckon I'm a bargain and would be in the lowest percentile. Where do I fit into the data?
If commenters want to try and explain where the numbers come from I'd be obliged - I've emailed the author too, I'll share anything I learn.




Comments