By Anna Bennett
Pico Playhouse is a small, intimate Los Angeles theater and on World Kidney Day, it hosted an impressive group of talent. Those on the stage and those in the audience. The production of the play Who Lives? written by Christopher Meeks, was a three year labor of love by producer/advocate/survivor Lori Hartwell of the Renal Support Network.
Christopher Meeks is a very talented writer with an impressive Hollywood resume. He developed the idea for writing Who Lives? when he stumbled across the Life Magazine article that dubbed this early Seattle effort the "Life or Death Committee" ( Dr. Blagg reports "We called it the Admissions Committee" (pdf link). This is a fictional story based on a real, medical history altering period of time in Seattle.)
Seattle in the 1960's was at the heart of dialysis's Wild West period. A time when inaction meant death. A time of intense, hands on collaboration. Who Lives? is a story glued together by one man's journey from perceived health to CKD5 diagnosis, to a fight for treatment and finally, a heroic (?) decision.
The dynamics of his relationships with his physician (identified as a resident), his wife, his secretary, dialysis staff and the committee are the touchstones of the many journeys that a person with CKD5 must take. A medical journey, a personal journey and an ethical journey. This was true in 1960 and still just as true today.
Bill saw the Committee as a dialysis version of 12 Angry Men. High on discussion, debate and a cast of exaggerated individuals. I saw them as a Greek chorus - giving voice to each aspect of the story - fleshing out ideas and social concerns - all the isms were represented, racism, ageism, sexism... all of the ugly in society was addressed, and a cliched romantic view of the future was proffered from a play set in 1963. Unfortunately, we don't have flying cars in the 21st century and we still have all the ism's, we just sublimate them. No conclusions are offered by Mr. Meeks - but I don't think that is what he was going for. Who lives? is thought provoking, sobering and heartbreaking. It is the story of a patient, turned advocate, his medical team, and the everyday people hand picked for an anonymous, thankless task of deciding who gets treatment and who will be left to die in nature's unmitigated grasp.
Thanks to the work of countless doctors, engineers, patients and others in Seattle, today no one need be left to die. The CKD decade, the '60s, produced heroes and technology that has sustained millions of lives. Who Lives? is a dramatization, and those with intimate knowledge of CKD5 and the work of the Seattle Artificial Kidney Center (now Northwest Kidney Centers) are best to suspend disbelief and see it as intended, as a work. It is art. The real story of those on the committee and the people who were chosen is still being told. Who Lives? is a great dramatic production that brings our history to the mainstream.
Who Lives? has a familiar Hollywood cast. (Two with CKD5 who have transplants) The star, playing the central character Gabriel, is Matt Gottleib - his portrayal of Patient #14 is an amazing journey.
Monica Himmel plays Margaret, his beautiful, amazingly dressed, long suffering caretaker/wife. Her attempt to find balance in a helpless (and seemingly hopeless) situation is poignant and moving. We see her wordless suffering in everyday tasks - breakfast, doing laundry - her portrayal does every CKD spouse/caretaker proud.
Richard Adkins had a wordless yet moving role. He brought voice to the soundtrack with his violin, it sets a mournful tone for the dialogue to come, and his virtuosity adds beauty to the production.
Rachel Kimsey plays committee member Alice, a pert, idealistic, sexy coed. Rachel plays Alice as the voice of the future. One imagines Alice finishing school, jumping in a van and motoring off to Woodstock, before settling down as a professor at a liberal arts college.
The Director Joe Ochman brought these characters to their full potential, and showcased Mr. Meeks words in a brilliant, straightforward production. What you see on stage is raw emotion filtered through a very talented cast.
Rounding out the cast is Matt Crabtree as Dr. Shuster, a young doctor just starting his career, Dale Wade Davis (CKD5 with transplant) is Lazlo, an everyman, the voice of the people who is ever so distracted by the beautiful coed Alice.
R. Martin Klein (CKD5, transplant) pays dual roles as Baxter/McKnight. Baxter is a grating, power hungry committee member, and then Mr. Klein turns it around and plays a patient slowly declining, suffering, who wants to end it all.
Tracey Rooney plays dual roles as Jenny, secretary to Gabriel and Nurse to Gabriel. She too, is the voice of what is to come in the role of secretary, and in the role of nurse, she brings a dissociative medical proficiency to the dialysis scenes - she truly is a chameleon. It took me two scenes to realize that she was playing dual roles.
The mother and father of this fictional version of the committee were played by Alice Ensor as Francine and John Timmons as Father William. Ms. Ensor played Francine as a blousey 1950's housewife who hides a sharp intellect, a depth of perception and observation that grounds the committee, all hidden behind the facade of insecurity, school runs and subservient mannerisms. And finally, John Timmons in the role of Father William is the head of the committee, a voice of reason, who although clad in the garb of a Catholic Priest, negotiates like a hardened litigator.
Bravo to Lori Hartwell, the many hands of RSN staff and volunteers, Christopher Meeks, the cast and the crew. This production is a very special tribute to those who came before us, and a message of hope for the future.
Hopefully we are long past the days of dialysis rationing, and our new heroes are those developing portable high dose dialysis, better more efficient anti rejection medication and a support infrastructure like that of the Northwest Kidney Centers. All those who continue to work so that a CKD diagnosis does not mean an end to the life one wishes to live.
Recent Comments
includes TV's best portrayal of dialyzor
includes TV's best portrayal of dialyzor